hankster
11-02-2005, 01:22 AM
Article written by Big Jim Greenemeyer
How the serrators cut - First, serrations are made up of peaks and valleys but since it's only the peaks that touch the comm (if the valley touches the comm, there are no serrations left) this is what we concern ourselves with.
Second, I'm listing the serrations on the different cutters and brushes by the number of serrations per inch measured from peak-to-peak.
Also, I found that the "stack" of serrations on a brush can start in a peak or a valley The only brushes I found that start with the peaks were the T#4500's and the T#4455. Nothing strange there-they are the same compound. The only difference is the standup vs. laydown comfiguration. The number of serrations per inch indicate how "fine" or "coarse" the serrations are but not how many are necessarily on each brush.
Since the dictionarys don't list the word "Serrater" we can make history here. Do we spell the tool that makes serrations a "Serrater" or "Serrator" . I'm not an English teacher but I say "Serrator", just looks better. If anyone out there knows any contradictory rule in English that says it would be proper to spell it the other way, let me know.
So whipping out a magnifier and a steel machinist scale I did some measuring. Here are the results.
SPI = Serrations Per Inch.
PROMATCH SERRATOR TOOL: 36 SPI
INTEGY SERRATOR TOOL: 32 spi (Same as the P-94 brush).
TRINITY SERRATOR TOOL: 40 SPI (but much shallower than the others).
TRINITY #4499 Brush: 44 SPI
TRINITY #4500 Brush: 56 SPI
TRINITY #4455 Brush: 56 SPI
TRINITY #4383E (P-94) 32 SPI (Matches Integy tool).
TRINITY #4380E (P-94) 32 SPI
TRINITY #4383 brush: 56 SPI
REEDY #767 Brush: 56 SPI
Putnam Pro "green": 44 SPI
Putnam Pro "red" : 44 SPI
Putnam Pro "blue" : 56 SPI
I couldn't figure a way to accurately measure serration depth. The Integy and ProMatch serrator tools "look" to be about the same.
What if any difference there is in a "fine" or "coarse" serration as far as power output, I'm not sure yet. But it is general thought that a finer serration is easier on the comm.
This motor tip is from Big Jim Greenemeyer.
How the serrators cut - First, serrations are made up of peaks and valleys but since it's only the peaks that touch the comm (if the valley touches the comm, there are no serrations left) this is what we concern ourselves with.
Second, I'm listing the serrations on the different cutters and brushes by the number of serrations per inch measured from peak-to-peak.
Also, I found that the "stack" of serrations on a brush can start in a peak or a valley The only brushes I found that start with the peaks were the T#4500's and the T#4455. Nothing strange there-they are the same compound. The only difference is the standup vs. laydown comfiguration. The number of serrations per inch indicate how "fine" or "coarse" the serrations are but not how many are necessarily on each brush.
Since the dictionarys don't list the word "Serrater" we can make history here. Do we spell the tool that makes serrations a "Serrater" or "Serrator" . I'm not an English teacher but I say "Serrator", just looks better. If anyone out there knows any contradictory rule in English that says it would be proper to spell it the other way, let me know.
So whipping out a magnifier and a steel machinist scale I did some measuring. Here are the results.
SPI = Serrations Per Inch.
PROMATCH SERRATOR TOOL: 36 SPI
INTEGY SERRATOR TOOL: 32 spi (Same as the P-94 brush).
TRINITY SERRATOR TOOL: 40 SPI (but much shallower than the others).
TRINITY #4499 Brush: 44 SPI
TRINITY #4500 Brush: 56 SPI
TRINITY #4455 Brush: 56 SPI
TRINITY #4383E (P-94) 32 SPI (Matches Integy tool).
TRINITY #4380E (P-94) 32 SPI
TRINITY #4383 brush: 56 SPI
REEDY #767 Brush: 56 SPI
Putnam Pro "green": 44 SPI
Putnam Pro "red" : 44 SPI
Putnam Pro "blue" : 56 SPI
I couldn't figure a way to accurately measure serration depth. The Integy and ProMatch serrator tools "look" to be about the same.
What if any difference there is in a "fine" or "coarse" serration as far as power output, I'm not sure yet. But it is general thought that a finer serration is easier on the comm.
This motor tip is from Big Jim Greenemeyer.